NIL Money: How College Athletes Can Keep What They Earn

Short answer: College athletes can now earn real money from their name, image and likeness (NIL) — and the IRS treats almost all of it as self-employment income with nothing withheld. Set aside 30% to 40% of every payment for taxes, pay yourself a steady monthly "salary" instead of spending each deposit, protect your eligibility and your income with good contracts and insurance, and plan as if the money stops after college. Nothing here is financial advice.

College athletes can now earn millions before they play a professional down — and most of them will be taxed, budgeted and advised like a small business owner for the first time in their lives. A 20-year-old with a $500,000 deal faces the same questions a founder does: what do I owe, what can I spend, and what happens when the money stops?

The stakes rose sharply when a federal judge approved the House v. NCAA settlement in June 2025. Schools can now pay athletes directly, up to roughly $20.5 million per school in 2025–26 and about $21.3 million in 2026–27, on top of brand deals from outside companies. Any outside deal worth $600 or more must now be reported through NIL Go, a clearinghouse run with Deloitte and enforced by the new College Sports Commission ^[5][6].

Bigger checks make the basics more important, not less. This guide walks through four questions every NIL athlete — and every parent — should be able to answer.

Who's earning the most right now

Miami quarterback Darian Mensah tops college sports at an estimated $6.5 million for the 2026 season, according to On3's July 2026 rankings. Since July 1, 2026, On3 values players by their current contract with the school or collective, not by social-media reach, so these figures are closer to a salary than a marketing estimate ^[1]. The top 10 by On3 NIL valuation:

- 1. Darian Mensah — Miami, football (QB): $6.5 million

- 2. Milan Momcilovic — Kentucky, basketball (PF): $6.0 million

- 3. Flory Bidunga — Louisville, basketball (C): $6.0 million

- 4. Dante Moore — Oregon, football (QB): $5.0 million

- 5. Jeremiah Smith — Ohio State, football (WR): $5.0 million

- 6. Tounde Yessoufou — St. John's, basketball (SF): $5.0 million

- 7. Thomas Haugh — Florida, basketball (SF): $5.0 million

- 8. Trinidad Chambliss — Ole Miss, football (QB): $5.0 million

- 9. Massamba Diop — Gonzaga, basketball (C): $5.0 million

- 10. Tyran Stokes — Kansas, basketball (SF): $5.0 million

The headline numbers hide how thin the top is. Opendorse data on Power 4 football players — the best-paid group in college sports — found about two-thirds earn under $10,000 a year and only 0.3% clear $1 million ^[2]. Whether an athlete earns $6 million or $6,000, the same four money questions apply.

How are NIL earnings taxed, and how much should you set aside?

Set aside 30% to 40% of every NIL payment the day it lands — closer to 40% in a high-tax state or once earnings pass six figures. NIL money arrives with nothing withheld, and the IRS treats it as self-employment income ^[3].

Two federal taxes, not one. Brand deals, appearances, autograph signings and sponsored posts are reported on Schedule C. That income owes regular income tax plus a 15.3% self-employment tax for Social Security and Medicare. The Social Security piece (12.4%) applies to the first $184,500 of 2026 earnings; Medicare (2.9%) has no cap. You must file once net self-employment earnings reach just $400 ^[2].

Self-employment tax is the surprise. Because it is figured before the $16,100 standard deduction, an athlete who "didn't make enough to owe taxes" still does. Here is the estimated 2026 federal bill for a single filer with no other income:

- $20,000 net NIL profit: $2,826 self-employment tax + $199 income tax = $3,025 total (about 15%)

- $50,000 net NIL profit: $7,065 self-employment tax + $2,667 income tax = $9,732 total (about 19%)

- $100,000 net NIL profit: $14,130 self-employment tax + $8,235 income tax = $22,365 total (about 22%)

- $250,000 net NIL profit: $29,851 self-employment tax + $37,103 income tax = $66,954 total (about 27%)

- $1,000,000 net NIL profit: $56,171 self-employment tax + $310,813 income tax = $366,984 total (about 37%)

These estimates assume 2026 brackets, the standard deduction and the 20% qualified business income deduction where it applies; self-employment tax includes the 0.9% Additional Medicare Tax above $200,000. State income tax comes on top of every figure above.

State tax is a second layer. Your home state can tax everything you earn, and states where you do the work — an out-of-state shoot or signing — can tax that piece. California tops out at 13.3%. Arkansas became the first state to exempt NIL income in 2025, but only money paid by the school ^[4].

Things that catch athletes off guard:

- No form doesn't mean no tax. Starting in 2026, payers only issue a 1099-NEC at $2,000 or more (up from $600). All NIL income is taxable either way ^[2].

- Free stuff is income. A car, gear, housing or meals from a sponsor are taxed at fair market value — and you need cash to pay that bill.

- Revenue-share "royalties" are a gray area. Some schools split payments into royalties (no self-employment tax) and services. The IRS hasn't blessed that split, so don't spend the difference.

- Pay quarterly. If you expect to owe $1,000 or more, estimated payments are due April 15, June 15, September 15 and January 15. A first-year earner with no prior tax bill is usually exempt in year one — but not year two ^[2].

- Deduct real business costs. Agent fees, contract review, tax prep, travel to appearances and content production reduce both income tax and self-employment tax. Keep every receipt.

How do you budget when income comes in uneven waves?

Pay yourself a steady salary from a holding account, and never budget off the size of the last deposit. NIL money tends to arrive in bursts — a signing bonus, a revenue-share installment, a few one-off appearance checks — and the average third-party deal is a one-time payment of about $6,200, not a recurring contract ^[2].

Use a four-account system. Every NIL payment goes into one inbox account, then gets split the same day:

1. Tax account — 30% to 40%, untouched until quarterly payments are due.

2. Holding ("payroll") account — the rest of what you plan to live on this year.

3. Spending account — a fixed monthly transfer from holding, like a paycheck.

4. Emergency and goals account — savings and investments once the first three are covered.

Set your "salary" from guaranteed money only. Add up what is contractually locked in for the next 12 months (revenue share, signed deals), subtract taxes, and divide by 12. Treat anything uncertain — a possible bonus, a deal still in talks — as zero until it clears. When a windfall lands, it refills holding and savings; it does not raise the monthly paycheck.

Build a bigger cushion than a salaried worker would. Aim for six months of expenses, not three. A coaching change, transfer, injury or collective that runs dry can stop NIL income overnight, while rent and a car payment keep coming.

Keep fixed costs at "normal job" levels. Don't sign a lease or take on a payment you couldn't cover on an ordinary entry-level salary. Lifestyle is easy to raise and painful to cut.

Plan for the off-season and the end of eligibility. NIL value often peaks in season and drops after a player's final game. Budget across the calendar year, and keep enough in holding to cover the gap between your last NIL check and your first post-college paycheck.

How do you protect what you earn — and your future?

Protection starts with paperwork and people, not products: a clean contract, a fair agent fee, reported deals and insurance against the injury that ends the income. Most NIL losses come from bad agreements, skipped compliance steps and trusted people, not from the market.

Protect your eligibility. Every third-party deal worth $600 or more must be submitted to NIL Go, the clearinghouse run by Deloitte for the College Sports Commission. Through July 1, 2026, it approved 95% of deals by count but only about 80% by dollar value — large deals get the most scrutiny ^[2]. Get approval before you spend the money.

Read every contract with a professional. Check the term, exclusivity (can you sign with a competing brand?), termination and morals clauses, who owns the content you create, and what happens if you transfer. A sports or entertainment attorney's review costs far less than a bad multi-year deal.

Keep agent fees in line. Industry guidance generally puts fair commissions at 0% to 3% on revenue share and collective money, 10% to 15% on deals that come to you, and 15% to 20% on deals the agent sourced. Above 20% is widely seen as predatory. Confirm the agent is registered under your state's athlete-agent law ^[2].

Use an LLC for the right reasons. A single-member LLC doesn't cut your taxes or shield you from your own conduct. It does keep your Social Security number off brand paperwork and gives your name, logo and trademarks a home that survives a transfer — as long as you never mix business and personal money. An S-corp election usually only pays off at roughly $80,000 to $100,000 or more of net profit.

Insure the income, not just the body. Ask about these four kinds of coverage:

- Loss-of-value and permanent total disability coverage — common for athletes with real draft potential.

- Disability income insurance — replaces earnings if an injury ends your playing days.

- Umbrella liability — covers lawsuits over a car accident or a post gone wrong.

- Health insurance — know what the school covers, and what happens after eligibility ends.

Guard against people, not just markets. Sudden money attracts "opportunities." Don't co-sign loans, lend money you need back, or invest in a friend's business or a hot tip. Keep financial logins to yourself, review every statement, and use advisors who are licensed and paid transparently.

Mind financial aid. NIL income shows up on the FAFSA two years later and can shrink need-based aid. Large cash balances in savings count against aid too, while retirement accounts do not ^[2].

What does a long-term plan look like, on and off the field?

A good plan assumes the money stops after college — and treats a pro contract as a bonus, not the base case. NCAA data puts the odds of a draft-eligible football player being drafted at about 1.4%, and men's basketball at 1.0% ^[7].

On the field: the money order of operations.

1. Taxes first, every payment, into the tax account.

2. Emergency fund of six months of expenses in a high-yield savings account.

3. Roth IRA. NIL self-employment income counts as earned income, so athletes can contribute up to $7,500 in 2026 if their income is under the IRS limit. A 19-year-old is likely in the lowest tax bracket of their life, which is when Roth money is cheapest. Retirement accounts also don't count as assets on the FAFSA ^[2].

4. Solo 401(k) or SEP-IRA for bigger earners — a solo 401(k) allows up to $24,500 in employee deferrals for 2026, and up to $72,000 combined with employer contributions ^[2].

5. Low-cost, diversified index funds in a taxable brokerage account with what's left. Skip concentrated bets, crypto pushed by friends and private "opportunities."

Why starting at 19 matters. Maxing a Roth IRA for four college years — $7,500 a year from ages 19 to 22 — could grow to roughly $600,000 by age 65 at a hypothetical 7% average annual return, with no further contributions. Returns are not guaranteed, but time in the market is the one advantage young athletes have that pros twice their age don't.

Off the field: build the second career now.

- Finish the degree. A scholarship covering a degree that would otherwise cost six figures is often the most valuable asset in the deal.

- Use your platform while it's big. Internships, informational interviews with sponsors' executives, and an audience you own (email list, content brand) all outlast eligibility.

- Protect your name. Your personal brand is the business. What you post at 20 shows up in job interviews at 30.

- Write a transition budget. Know what your life costs on a regular salary, and have 6 to 12 months of runway banked before your final season ends.

Put a team in place early. At minimum: a CPA who handles multi-state self-employment income, an attorney who reviews contracts, and a fee-transparent, licensed financial professional. Meet them before the first big deal closes, not in April.

The NIL money checklist

- Open separate accounts: inbox, tax, holding, spending and emergency.

- Move 30%–40% to taxes: every payment, the same day it lands.

- Clear every deal: submit each third-party deal of $600 or more to NIL Go before spending it.

- Get contracts reviewed: use an attorney, and confirm your agent's fee and registration.

- Pay estimated taxes quarterly: April 15, June 15, September 15 and January 15.

- Keep records: save receipts and every 1099 — even small deals are taxable.

- Build the cushion: six months of expenses in savings.

- Save aggressively: bank every dollar you don't need to live on.

- A Bentley is not a living necessity. A paid-off used car with good brakes is.

- A $50,000 watch tells the same time as a $50 one. The other $49,950 can tell your future.

- Courtside seats for the whole crew? Wait until the pro contract, not the NIL check.

- Rule of thumb: if you can't buy it twice in cash, you can't afford it once.

- Review your coverage: disability, liability and health insurance.

- Finish the degree: and plan for life after eligibility.

Find an advisor who understands NIL

Most financial professionals have never worked with self-employment income that arrives in waves, NIL Go reporting or a two-year FAFSA lag. Look for someone who is licensed, explains how they are paid up front, and has helped athletes or other self-employed clients before.

The athletes who come out ahead aren't always the ones who earned the most. They're the ones who treated a short, uneven income stream like the small business it legally is.

This article is for educational purposes only and is not tax, legal or investment advice. Tax figures are estimates based on 2026 federal rules for a single filer and will differ with your state, filing status and deductions. Talk to a qualified tax professional before making decisions.

TopHolding publishes free, unbiased financial education. No bias. No paywall. No upselling.